Hi! I’m Ms Nellie Lim, a teacher at Lil’ but Mighty. Today, we will take a closer look at some common mistakes that students make when writing their introduction and build-up paragraphs and how we can address them. These paragraphs help to set the story and show what happened that led to the problem. Hence, they are of utmost importance!
Some common pitfalls in narrative writing include the following:
- Starting the story much too early before the action
- Having multiple settings for the introduction
- Including too many dialogues in the build-up
Let’s look at each of these pitfalls in closer detail and how to tackle them:
1. Starting the story much too early before the action
For instance, let’s imagine that a student has chosen this picture for the topic Gratitude:
Now read the student’s – let’s call him Simon – storyline and introduction based on the given topic and picture:
Simon’s storyline
Main character: Jimmy
Character 2: Biscuit, his pet golden retriever
Problem: Jimmy is attacked by an aggressive stray dog at the park while playing frisbee with Biscuit
Simon’s Introduction (Version 1)
Now what is wrong with Simon’s introduction? Let’s use these prompting questions to guide us:
- Did it include irrelevant details?
- Did it include too many unnecessary descriptions?
- After removing a large chunk of it, is the storyline unaffected by the change?
If the answer to all the above questions is a ‘Yes’, then this student has made a common mistake of starting his story too early from the action.
How can we resolve this?
By analysing what Simon wrote, let’s see what we can remove and then modify it.
The parts in red that have been cancelled out are irrelevant and unnecessary descriptions:
Instead, we should move the story forward by inserting key details such as where Jimmy brought his pet dog to so that the story moves on to the build-up (where they encounter an aggressive stray dog):
Version 2 (modified from Version 1)
Can you see that in the modified version, I have:
- modified the speech at the beginning so that it doesn’t have to start with Jimmy waking up and brushing his teeth.
- replaced unnecessary descriptions such as the flavour of his toothpaste and the design of his toothbrush with the place description using sensory details such as what he saw and heard at the park.
- provided a link to the next paragraph – I have added in a thought i.e. Jimmy decided to play a game of frisbee with his pet dog, Biscuit. This is so that it will link nicely to the next paragraph (Build-up) where an aggressive stray dog comes into the picture.
2. Having multiple settings in the introduction
Another error that Simon made in his introduction is that by starting the story with his main character waking up, it would mean that he would later need to shift the setting to the park. Having multiple settings in the introduction is not a good idea because it slows down the action with unnecessary details.
In order to tackle this problem, I have modified the speech in the introduction. In doing so, I have fixed the setting of the story at the park instead of having to shift it from Jimmy’s bedroom to the park. This allows the story to move at a faster pace and makes the reader keen to read on and find out what would happen next in the park. As far as possible, you should set the story where the problem will take place. For instance, if the story is about a girl nearly drowning in the ocean, the story should begin with her arriving at the seaside for a picnic with her friends, instead of waking up in her bedroom at home or meeting her friends at the mall.
Remember also that in the examination, you would need to impress the examiner with a story in 150 words. As such, it would be ideal that the story you write contains details that are not only necessary to help move the action forward but are also important in answering the given topic.
3. Including too many dialogues in the build-up
Sometimes, students include too many dialogues in their story, hoping that it will make the story engaging but often, they add too much causing the language to be monotonous. Having too many dialogues also takes away a student’s chances of inserting descriptions while moving the story forward. Let’s take a look at the build-up paragraph which Simon has written. Take note that the paragraph below is continued from his version of the introduction (Version 1).
Simon’s Build-up (Version 1)
Now how can we improve on Simon’s build-up? Let’s use these prompting questions to guide us:
- Did it include irrelevant details?
- Did it include too many unnecessary dialogues?
- After removing a large chunk of it, is the storyline unaffected by the change?
If the answer to all the above questions is a ‘Yes’, then let’s help Simon to work on it, especially on having too many dialogues in the build-up.
How can we resolve this?
By analysing what Simon wrote, the parts in red are those that we can remove and/or modify:
Instead of adding so many dialogues, what can we do to simplify this?
Simon’s Build-up (Version 2)
To tackle the problem, in the modified version, I have:
- retained only one dialogue so as to allow readers to understand how Jimmy met the second character, Mr Tan.
- replaced all the remaining dialogues with actions and/or indirect speech such as “greeted his elderly neighbour with a warm smile”, “told him that he would like to borrow a frisbee from him”.
- simplified the last part to describing where Mr Tan went, leaving the readers to imagine that at this point, the aggressive stray dog appears while Jimmy was sitting at a bench.
To sum up, let’s recap what we can do to avoid the three pitfalls I have mentioned using this table below: